Best Card Sleeves: Magic Card Protector Reviews of 2019

The card sleeves are one of the most important things when it comes to the magic accessories. Protecting the cards is necessary because, after a long time use, the continuous use & weather effects can damage them. Especially, when you have massive games like Pokémon, MTG, or Yu-Gi-Oh!, you need top-quality card protectors for them. But, how will you pick up the most suitable sleeves for your magic cards?best card protectors

Well, I have filtered a list of the most sought products available today which will help you to choose one. Let’s have a look.

Best Card Sleeves

1) Ultra Pro Card Sleeves (100 Piece)

Ultra Pro Card SleevesThis pack of card sleeves from Ultra Pro is perfect for keeping the magic, sports, and game cards. It is one of the most famous and used card protector brands.

Specifications & features of the Ultra Pro Card Sleeves are:

  • The package includes a hundred pieces of clear card shields.
  • These sleeves offer durable quality and excellent protection.
  • They have the standard sizes which are perfectly fit for the cards of games like Pokémon, MTG, etc.
  • They can last up to six years and more if treated well.
  • You can put each card in a separate sleeve which provides an extra layer of protection.
  • All these card sleeves are acid-free & have sizes of 2 5/8-inch by 3 5/8-inch.  


2) KMC Full Size Hyper Matte Sleeves (80-Pack)

KMC Full Size Hyper Matte SleevesIf you are participating in the tournament, then you should keep these card sleeves with you. These full-sized matte protective sleeves from KMC will save your card’s condition from any weather effect.

Specifications & features of KMC Matte Card Protectors are:

  • Due to the matte finish, these covers have less slicks than ordinary glossy sleeves.
  • This package includes 80 different sleeves to protect your magic cards.
  • The protective covers are perfect for gaming cards like MTG, Pokémon, Weiss, etc.
  • Each card sleeve has a size of 91 by 66 mm.
  • A unique embossing process makes the sleeves less slick & shiny than the other standard matte finished card protectors.
  • They can serve from eight years to fifteen years as magic card protective sleeves.


3) Dragon Shield 100 Protective Sleeves

Dragon Shield Matte BlackFrom one of the most renowned brands, you will get a pack of 100 protective card sleeves. The Dragon Shield is a well-known manufacturer for providing sturdy, attractive, and consistent-performing card protectors.

Features & specs of Dragon Shield Card Sleeves are:

  • In a single box, you will get 100 units of card protectors which are enough to store your magic cards, game cards, sports cards, etc.
  • The solid box itself can store above 75 cards with sleeves.
  • On the top of the box, there is a printed label on which you can add your info.
  • If you have a card size of 63mm by 88mm, then this protective sleeve is perfect for it.
  • Best for use & store the gaming cards of Pokémon, Making the Gathering (MTG), etc.
  • If you take proper care, then this pack of card sleeves can last for eight years and more.


4) Ultra Pro Soft Sleeves (Ten Packs)’

From Ultra Pro, you will get ten different packs of card sleeves to keep your baseball cards, game cards, and other sports cards at safe places. Each package of protectors contains 100 sleeves which mean you will have a thousand of protecting sleeves for storing cards.10 (Ten) Pack Lot of 100 Soft Sleeves

Specifications & features of Ultra Pro Soft Sleeves are:

  • All the sleeves are made of the Polyurethane material to get premium quality.
  • The crystal clear design helps to display and identify a card without taking it out from the cover.
  • These card protectors are perfect for storing the cards like football cards, baseball cards, hockey cards, gaming cards like Pokémon, YuGiOh, MTG, Dragonball Z, etc.
  • Each sleeve has a size of 3 by 2.5 by 4 inches.
  • The design is acid-free to provide an extra layer of protection to the cards.


5) BCW Premium Black Double Matte Card Sleeve Protectors

100 Premium Black Double MatteBCW offers you a pack of 100 card sleeves for storing your magic cards, sports cards, and game cards. These protectors are well enough to store, protect, and shuffle the cards quickly.

Specifications and features of BCW Premium Card Sleeves are:

  • The double matte finish helps you to handle the cards comfortably.
  • On the front side, the clear matte finish helps to display and identify the card.
  • A pack of 100 sleeves is enough to keep all of your magic and game cards like Pokémon, MTG, Yu-Gi-Oh, etc.
  • Each sleeve is acid-free and made with 0% PVC material.
  • These non-glare, transparent, and matte finish protectors fit perfectly with the cards of 2½” by 3½” sizes.


6) Mayday Games 7106 Premium Magnum Sleeves

Mayday Games 7106Mayday Games introduced the premium sleeves for protecting the sports cards, game cards, and magic cards. The MDG7106 pack from the company contains a total of 80 sleeves.

Features and specifications of Mayday Games Magnum Card Protectors are:

  • Each card sleeve has a size of 65mm by 100 mm which is quite enough to store any type of card.
  • As this is a unique designed series of sleeves, it is a lot thicker (almost 125% thicker) than the standard sleeves.
  • The protective cover is made of the transparent polyurethane material to provide premium quality.
  • No PVC material used in making the sleeves and they are acid-free.
  • If you take proper care of the sleeves, then they can last more than three years.


7) TitanShield Board Game and Matte Trading Card Sleeves

Standard Size Board GameThe premium quality protector sleeves from TitanShield provide special protection to the cards of games and sports. You will get a total of 150 sleeves in this package.

Features and specifications of TitanShield Trading Card Sleeves are:

  • You can keep each of your cards in a separate sleeve to maintain its condition for a long time.
  • The surface of the cover is non-reflective and anti-slip which provide smooth operation and handling.
  • It is perfect for the gamers who love to play frequently shuffling card games.
  • If you are a professional card player, then you will love to have this pack of card protectors which are acid-free and of the archival grade.
  • These sleeves are best for storing and carrying the cards of MTG, Pokémon, etc. games and other sports cards.


Overall comparison

Let’s get a quick look at what the protective card sleeves offer:

NamePrice Per PackTotal UnitsSize of a Sleeve
Ultra Pro Standard$2.751002 5/8 x 3 5/8 Inches
KMC Full Size$6.99805.5 x 4  Inches
Dragon Shield Standard$10.991002 1/2 x 3 1/2 Inches
Ultra Pro Soft$0.9410002 5/8 X 3 5/8 Inches
BCW Premium$5.591002 1/2 x 3 1/2 Inches
Mayday Games Premium$5.98802.6 x 3.9 Inches
TitanShield Standard$9.991506 x 4 Inches


Apart from some differences, all the card protector sleeves mentioned here are of good quality. They all are entirely compatible for storing and keeping your magic cards, game cards, sports cards, etc. They will allow displaying the cards from the sleeves as well as help to maintain the condition of the cards for a longer time.

So, which brand and sleeve type will you prefer for storing your cards? Let the world know about your choice.

Good Luck!